Sepia
For New Year’s Eve this year Kevin and I decided to do something more low key with just the two of us, and of course that involved dining out somewhere fabulous in the city.
We chose to eat at Sepia in Chicago’s West Loop because it’s been on our list for a while and its reputation told us that it could be the perfect high class night for such a celebratory evening. Sepia, we learned, is pronounced SEE – PEE – AH, and comes from a type of pigment shade used in photography. See definition here.
Everything about Sepia was classy – the decor and vibe very rustic and vintage with classic flare, which made this establishment the perfect destination for a glamourous night out in one of the nation’s best cities.
Sepia required that guests order their special prix fixe menu on New Year’s Eve. You can find the entire menu here. Sometimes it’s hard to decide whether or not to order the prix fixe, mostly because there are always so many wonderful options on the regular menu. This evening, we didn’t have a choice, and when I’m dining at a restaurant with an outstanding reputation for excellence I usually prefer to order prix fixe anyways as it’s usually a seasonal menu and the chef usually prepares specialty items that usually aren’t featured on the regular menu. Usually with prix fixe menus you can indicate if you have an allergy or don’t eat meat, fish, etc. and the chef will be happy to customize the prix fixe for you. Because I don’t eat a lot of meat, I usually have to do this and at top restaurants they are usually more than happy to do this for you.
To start the night off, I ordered a glass of champagne and Kevin had a vodka tonic at the bar. There’s something about New Year’s and champagne – lately if I’m having a pre-dinner cocktail, I like to start with champagne. It’s too much to drink all night, but a great way to start off your night.
The seating area at Sepia is very cool – a real vintage and glamour feel. It felt like a special occasion. I especially loved the lighting and light fixtures. You could tell that they were trying to recreate sepia photography and it worked in such a subtle way.
We ordered a bottle of wine with our meal and per usual I’ve neglected to write down the name. It was a pinot noir and very, very good. Needless to say, they have a very impressive wine list at Sepia. Most everything on the list is pricey, but for occasions we like to order nicer bottles anyways so we decided to splurge.
The first course on our prix fixe menu was citrus marinated Nantucket bay scallops. This was one of my favorite items served. The scallops were cooked absolutely perfectly, and although different and probably not appetizing to all due to their preparation (more raw), they were incredibly fresh and clean tasting. This dish felt healthy and clean and the citrus flavors along with the chive melted in your mouth. Unfortunately I didn’t photograph my second favorite menu item, which was the second course – the chestnut soup with oxtail and black truffle. Of course, I asked for mine without oxtail which the chef was happy to accommodate. I think one of my favorite comfort foods or maybe even foods in general is soup because a great soup is all about flavor. This chestnut soup was unbelievable. The chestnut was very dominant, but also there were woodsy flavors and a pleasant black truffle aftertaste. The soup literally melted away in your mouth.
I didn’t take a photo of the third course either, which was Farro Risotto with foie gras and wild mushrooms. If there is one vegetable that I love, it’s mushrooms. My favorite are morels, but unfortunately because they are seasonal I only get to enjoy them at certain points during the year. Kevin and I are actually considering going on a morel mushroom trip this spring in Illinois to pick our own morels. I’ll post about that later this year. I ordered my risotto without foie gras and it was amazing. The key to risotto is being able to cook it perfectly so it isn’t mushy and sticky, and it was evident that Sepia didn’t need a lesson on how to cook its risotto perfectly. I think the theme of this meal was ‘melting in my mouth’….. because again this dish was so delicate and the flavors so strong that it just melted away in my mouth.
For our entrees, we had a choice between the grilled East Coast sturgeon with stewed cauliflower, saffron and gaeta olives or the braised wagyu beef short ribs with taro root puree and root vegetables. Kevin chose the wagu beef short ribs and I of course chose the sturgeon. Sturgeon is definitely not a fish I would typically order off of a menu when dining out, but Sepia prepared it so well. Many use sturgeon fish for their caviar, and also some to serve as entrees. My favorite part of the dish was the integration of cauliflower. I love so many vegetables but lately have loved eating dishes with and cooking with cauliflower. Many people use cauliflower to make a faux mashed potatoes and it really has that same creamy effect. The creaminess of the added cauliflower in the dish along with the bitterness of the olives were a very nice compliment to the sturgeon.
For dessert we had the option of ordering either the chocolate raspberry mousse with chocolate brownie, candied almonds and raspberry syrup (above, which is what I ordered) or the frozen vanilla parfait with granola crust and passion fruit champagne soup. The above picture of the chocolate raspberry mousse is deceiving because of the beautiful presentation! The mousse was served in a thin candy coating that was shaped like a pear. It was delicious. My only complaint is that it was a little much, but it was nice because Kevin and I could try each others. The combination of the chocolate and fruit infusions with raspberry and pear wear very tasty. I also tried Kevin’s and loved it, but it was incredibly sour and tangy. Some might argue that the sour flavors are too much, but it went really well with the frozen vanilla parfait and granola. It was incredibly refreshing and clean tasting, much like the starting scallop dish. I love chocolate and dessert, but I appreciate when a chef can end with something that leaves you feeling cleansed and clean.
I will definitely be back to Sepia to order from their regular menu. It was incredible, definitely on my favorite restaurant list for Chicago. I give it four out of five stars and can’t wait to go back!
Have you been to Sepia? What did you think?


































